Against the Enlightenment

My suspicion is that death means the complete annihilation of what you consider to be your self. That is, your conscious being plus the sum total of your memories, your senses, your accumulated knowledge, your personal nature, your character and temperament, and so on—all things that are, to the best of our understanding, consequences of the physical structure of the brain. We have no good reason to believe these aren’t all destroyed when the body dies and rots.

This is very much my own outlook. I can't see anything but oblivion being likely enough to take it seriously, though apparently many if not most people disagree. They can believe what they wish, of course, but to me it seems like wishful thinking born of desperation. I believe in nothing. And yet, I do think the idea of the oblivion that awaits me is terrifying, and have always dreaded death because I love life so much. Maybe that would change if I were to be subjected to some of the horrors that have engulfed so many societies in human history. Maybe I have been lucky.

I used to think that I would be on my deathbed fighting death, raging (like Dylan Thomas?) but now I have come to realize that if I live long enough (I'm 63) I'll likely be sick and tired, and what I'll really want is to be young again, which is impossible. So maybe I will surrender to it. As of now, I'm still dreading it. It will not be pretty.
 
This is very much my own outlook. I can't see anything but oblivion being likely enough to take it seriously, though apparently many if not most people disagree. They can believe what they wish, of course, but to me it seems like wishful thinking born of desperation.

Yes, I suspect that explains a great many human beliefs past and present (and future, no doubt).

I believe in nothing. And yet, I do think the idea of the oblivion that awaits me is terrifying, and have always dreaded death because I love life so much.


I can only imagine that it must be an even less appealing prospect to those who enjoy life. As someone who considers biological life a mostly bad deal forced on (initially) innocent beings, I nevertheless do not see death as the “merciful” escape from suffering some seem to conceive of it as, especially when one takes into account the process of dying itself, which can transform the most charmed life into an unbearable hell.

The great problem with pro-death reasoning is that those who make those arguments claim death means relief of suffering. But death does not appear to work that way. They fail to grasp the obvious point that relief is something you can only receive if you are alive and conscious to experience it. Death, by and large, occurs only after a prolonged period of suffering that continues growing worse until the mind and body are both overwhelmed. One’s last moments of conscious life are not likely to offer much in the way of relief.

I also do not believe that the oblivion of death is a state we can “know” in any sense. Though I do not subscribe to human myths of Paradise or of any other type of afterlife in which we continue our lives as before, I also suspect that basic consciousness, the “You” of consciousness, is a state that can re-emerge in one form or another. What dreams may come, etc. But that’s all mere speculation at best.
 
What is sleep? Why do we sleep away one third of our existence? Couldn't Evolution have shaped us so that the body can rest without this strange blackout state? This IS oblivion, isn't it? We "die" a small "death" every night we go to bed. If death is oblivion, then it can't be different from falling into a dreamless sleep; in fact, it must be even more relieving. There is nothing to regret: just complete wonderful oblivion.

And if it be that a spiritual part, soul, or other form of deeper "energy" or purer self continues on its way, then the wheel keeps spinning and we are back on track again.

Either way seems fine with me. Oblivion, or a continued adventure.

Another angle on this, is that we all experience the same sense of isolation from others, being trapped within a body. In sharing this sensation we could all be of a collective single consciousness within a larger organic entity, like the individual cells in a body. Some cells always fall off, but it doesn't really matter for they are replaced. Or like the leaves on the tree or the flowers, falling off, and being replaced. Mushrooms are not singular individuals, although it may appear so, but simply outcroppings of the same mycelium entity. Humans are also bound together by shared ties, genetical, chemical, ecological, social. Our sense of individual isolation is in away a deranged illusion. In my belief, the spiritual journey is all about finding our way back to the Whole; although materially this is a slow evolutionary process, and can't be intellectually & willfully forced against the laws and rythm of Nature; or things may be badly messed up, with much social & physical suffering. But the individual on the other hand, can make great strides on his inner level of spiritual maturity, and be an inspiration onto others.
 
Hello. New member. Anyway. Two cents. As much as it might comfort or despair me (depending on the day and mood) that the experience of being is tied to some indivisible spiritual component that continues on after death, there is to no rational reason to suggest anything like a soul exists, nor some permanent conscious energy or force. Now if you want to say atoms or what-not are still around, sure, but that is still by any practical metric, annihilation. I suppose in this way I am a materialist, but I just think of it as accepting the universe at face value (including verified scientific discoveries that I may never personally witness). I'm also sometimes a hard determinist which, if poetically described, is just as mystical as religious belief. Then again, when I read Ligotti, I believe this could be--a type of--Hell. But, in the words of Ruth Langmore, "I don't know shit about fuck."
 
Back
Top