Recent Reading

Don't take this personally. I'm familiar with Michael T. Cisco's work, and I like it. I don't share Ironrose's opinion, since I haven't read much of his work, nor have I read much of Strantzas. As for his opinion of Mark Samuels, I disagree.

That said, having a Ph.D. and all the other credentials you mentioned doesn't necessarily make someone a "good" weird fiction writer. H. P. Lovecraft never completed his formal education, yet he inspired all of them.

I think you should separate the author's prose from the author himself, and the author from the person.

Still, I think the final comparison you make with Ironrose, emphasizing authors we already know he doesn't enjoy, was unnecessary. Just saying.

Fair, sort of. What I wrote was to show that it is rather supercilious to suggest, given his background, education, and experience, that Cisco could not properly use a comma. That is what was suggested. I even stated the reply stating that whether one likes a particular author or not is another thing all together. What you write at the end makes no sense to me. It was just to show that Ironrose and myself appear to have very different tastes. Just saying and no offense taken or given.
 
No one can really comment about taste and why one does or doesn't like a particular work or author's style, however, it is sort of goofy to suggest that Michael Cisco does not how to punctuate a sentence. He has had an impeccable academic career at elite schools, including a PhD at NYU, and is a professor at city university NY. He is also highly lauded in the weird tales community to the point that Ligotti stated that Cisco, "elevated the field" or something to that point. It is fine to not like his work or style but it is hubris to indicate that he is in some way illiterate. I am guessing that you and I have vastly different notions about who is quality in contemporary weird literature as I believe that you have disparaged the work of both M. Samuels and Simon Stranzas, both of whom I believe to have been/are among the best we have today.,

As yet, I have not read 'The Tyrant', but I have read 'The Divinity Student' and quite enjoyed it. Let's not forget, as well, that TLO adjacent Grimscribe Press published 'Antisocieties' by Michael Cisco, fwiw. This latter is on my reading shortlist.
 
As yet, I have not read 'The Tyrant', but I have read 'The Divinity Student' and quite enjoyed it. Let's not forget, as well, that TLO adjacent Grimscribe Press published 'Antisocieties' by Michael Cisco, fwiw. This latter is on my reading shortlist.
I wish I could read more of his work. So far, I’ve only managed to read a couple of his stories in fan translations; his work is hardly available in Spanish. Michael T. Cisco certainly has his merits. Here he is at the fourth edition of NecronomiCon, a young Michael T. Cisco.

011_14a_1.jpg

Michael Cisco, Robert M. Price, and Joseph S. Pulver, Sr.
 
No one can really comment about taste and why one does or doesn't like a particular work or author's style, however, it is sort of goofy to suggest that Michael Cisco does not know how to punctuate a sentence. He has had an impeccable academic career at elite schools, including a PhD at NYU, and is a professor at city university NY. He is also highly lauded in the weird tales community to the point that Ligotti stated that Cisco, "elevated the field" or something to that point. It is fine to not like his work or style but it is hubris to indicate that he is in some way illiterate. I am guessing that you and I have vastly different notions about who is quality in contemporary weird literature as I believe that you have disparaged the work of both M. Samuels and Simon Stranzas, both of whom I believe to have been/are among the best we have today.,
I thought I was being nice, actually. I've met all sorts of educated people whose abilities did not live up to their education. So what? Also, as R says, he may be a fine human, but that does not make him a fine writer. And yes, I think Mark Samuels was a hack (and a crank, which doesn't help). When I got serious about reading/collecting this new Weird/Dark/Literary Horror, I thought I'd discovered a treasure trove, and the first writers I read seemed to support that. But now I've gotten around to a few whose work has fallen far short, and I'm having to sort that out.

PS. I've never read Strantzas. Should I?

PPS. I'm uneducated, so maybe I can't see the sophisticated way Cisco deploys commas, or other language. I didn't think he was illiterate. Maybe he needed to proofread? Maybe he thought he was being clever? I'm guessing the second.

PPPS. Thanks for reading. That's more than anyone can expect.

PPPPS. I've been waiting for this particular response. I knew someone would have something to say. And yes, it's more than taste. I thought the book would be good, but...

PPPPPS. I started with Unutterable Horror, and I tended to agree with Joshi at first, but now I have my doubts about him, too. That's okay, I'm still glad he's doing what he's doing.

PPPPPPS. ...no, I can't do it. (insert grinning cat emoticon here)
 
I thought I was being nice, actually. I've met all sorts of educated people whose abilities did not live up to their education. So what? Also, as R says, he may be a fine human, but that does not make him a fine writer. And yes, I think Mark Samuels was a hack (and a crank, which doesn't help). When I got serious about reading/collecting this new Weird/Dark/Literary Horror, I thought I'd discovered a treasure trove, and the first writers I read seemed to support that. But now I've gotten around to a few whose work has fallen far short, and I'm having to sort that out.

PS. I've never read Strantzas. Should I?

PPS. I'm uneducated, so maybe I can't see the sophisticated way Cisco deploys commas, or other language. I didn't think he was illiterate. Maybe he needed to proofread? Maybe he thought he was being clever? I'm guessing the second.

PPPS. Thanks for reading. That's more than anyone can expect.

PPPPS. I've been waiting for this particular response. I knew someone would have something to say. And yes, it's more than taste. I thought the book would be good, but...

PPPPPS. I started with Unutterable Horror, and I tended to agree with Joshi at first, but now I have my doubts about him, too. That's okay, I'm still glad he's doing what he's doing.

PPPPPPS. ...no, I can't do it. (insert grinning cat emoticon here)
OK. Sorry to have confused you with someone else on the Stranzas.
 
In an attempt to smooth things over a bit... I think many of us here have different literary tastes and opinions. Ironrose's take on Cisco is perfectly valid. Hell, it's weird fiction, plain and simple. And I think we all respect Mark Samuels, may he rest in peace, as a person. Now, if you don't enjoy his work or consider it a Ligotti pastiche, that's not something anyone can force you to change. I mean, no matter how much we might want to, we can't lie to ourselves about how we genuinely feel when reading something.

On a different note, since he's been brought up... Strantzas reminds me of Phillip Fracassi. I don't know whether there's any connection between the two.

But getting back to the point, I've noticed that quite often here on TLO, when someone criticizes an author's work, people seem to think they're attacking the author personally. I don't think that's ever really been the case here.

Why am I even arguing in favor of this? I don't know. I just like trying to be diplomatic whenever possible, and I don't particularly like seeing people being dismissed or talked down to simply because authors have become somewhat idealized figures nowadays. They're human beings, just like the rest of us.
 
In an attempt to smooth things over a bit... I think many of us here have different literary tastes and opinions. Ironrose's take on Cisco is perfectly valid. Hell, it's weird fiction, plain and simple. And I think we all respect Mark Samuels, may he rest in peace, as a person. Now, if you don't enjoy his work or consider it a Ligotti pastiche, that's not something anyone can force you to change. I mean, no matter how much we might want to, we can't lie to ourselves about how we genuinely feel when reading something.

On a different note, since he's been brought up... Strantzas reminds me of Phillip Fracassi. I don't know whether there's any connection between the two.

But getting back to the point, I've noticed that quite often here on TLO, when someone criticizes an author's work, people seem to think they're attacking the author personally. I don't think that's ever really been the case here.

Why am I even arguing in favor of this? I don't know. I just like trying to be diplomatic whenever possible, and I don't particularly like seeing people being dismissed or talked down to simply because authors have become somewhat idealized figures nowadays. They're human beings, just like the rest of us.
"But getting back to the point, I've noticed that quite often here on TLO, when someone criticizes an author's work, people seem to think they're attacking the author personally. I don't think that's ever really been the case here."

Yes. Thank you, R. Throughout my entire half-assed life, I've known two types of artists that I struggle with: one type is the person I genuinely admire and enjoy, but whose work is so bad I dread having to voice an opinion on it. The other is the person whose work I admire, but who I don't want anything to do with personally. That's why I generally try to avoid making the acquaintance of anyone whose work I like. I am generalizing here. (Edward Ka-Spel is a decent person. I don't really know him, but at least I can admire him. This is a good thing.)

PS. Fracassi. Another of my disappointments. This subject is Ironrose's Burden.

PPS. I've just begun a Broodcomb book. Broodcomb needs more love.
 
"But getting back to the point, I've noticed that quite often here on TLO, when someone criticizes an author's work, people seem to think they're attacking the author personally. I don't think that's ever really been the case here."

Yes. Thank you, R. Throughout my entire half-assed life, I've known two types of artists that I struggle with: one type is the person I genuinely admire and enjoy, but whose work is so bad I dread having to voice an opinion on it. The other is the person whose work I admire, but who I don't want anything to do with personally. That's why I generally try to avoid making the acquaintance of anyone whose work I like. I am generalizing here. (Edward Ka-Spel is a decent person. I don't really know him, but at least I can admire him. This is a good thing.)

PS. Fracassi. Another of my disappointments. This subject is Ironrose's Burden.

PPS. I've just begun a Broodcomb book. Broodcomb needs more love.
In another thread here, I shared an opinion about Ramsey Campbell, but people made it sound as though I was dismissing his work. That's not the case at all. Quite the opposite: I was emphasizing that he's one of those authors who continues to write consistently, even at his age, rather than wasting his time.

And when I say that Ramsey Campbell is better known for his contributions to the Cthulhu Mythos than for anything else, I'm not saying he's a bad writer, that his other novels are bad, or anything of the sort. I just feel that's the reality. Y'Golonac has more backstory than any other creation by a Lovecraftian "successor," despite having appeared in only one story: "Cold Print."

And as for what you said about Cisco not being in the same vein as Ligotti... I have to agree with you there. Thomas Ligotti belongs to roughly the same generation, and he's the only one who has truly established a school of his own, perhaps with Stephen King being the only one to overshadow him. But we know King doesn't really count here, at least in my opinion, because he sold out to the mainstream... and he's not that great a writer anyway. I've had some truly awful disappointments with Stephen King over the years. Better not even get me started on Stephen King...
 
In another thread here, I shared an opinion about Ramsey Campbell, but people made it sound as though I was dismissing his work. That's not the case at all. Quite the opposite: I was emphasizing that he's one of those authors who continues to write consistently, even at his age, rather than wasting his time.

And when I say that Ramsey Campbell is better known for his contributions to the Cthulhu Mythos than for anything else, I'm not saying he's a bad writer, that his other novels are bad, or anything of the sort. I just feel that's the reality. Y'Golonac has more backstory than any other creation by a Lovecraftian "successor," despite having appeared in only one story: "Cold Print."

And as for what you said about Cisco not being in the same vein as Ligotti... I have to agree with you there. Thomas Ligotti belongs to roughly the same generation, and he's the only one who has truly established a school of his own, perhaps with Stephen King being the only one to overshadow him. But we know King doesn't really count here, at least in my opinion, because he sold out to the mainstream... and he's not that great a writer anyway. I've had some truly awful disappointments with Stephen King over the years. Better not even get me started on Stephen King...
I wanted to leave multiple emojis in response to this, but it only lets me do one, so it's thumbs up! This is a complex subject, complicated by personal taste, but I do like these conversations. As to Campbell, I've only read three, and while I had issues with his prose, and other small things, his endings were fantastic. I mean fantastic. As in really good. They go into tragic, mystical, horrific and beautiful slow motion. This makes me want to read more, and I do have more. Also, it's possible his short stories are best...

PS. That said, I'm always skeptical about "Lovecraftian". I like HPL, but I am afraid of epigones... Same with Conan, though I haven't read any since childhood.

PPS. The secret (I think) to having and sharing a controversial opinion is to not be too emotionally attached to it. This is a worthy goal, and I try.

PPPS. I promise not to mention one S. King. I've only read one novel (The Shining) and he...does go on. And on. Oops there I did mention him after all.
 
I wanted to leave multiple emojis in response to this, but it only lets me do one, so it's thumbs up! This is a complex subject, complicated by personal taste, but I do like these conversations. As to Campbell, I've only read three, and while I had issues with his prose, and other small things, his endings were fantastic. I mean fantastic. As in really good. They go into tragic, mystical, horrific and beautiful slow motion. This makes me want to read more, and I do have more. Also, it's possible his short stories are best...

PS. That said, I'm always skeptical about "Lovecraftian". I like HPL, but I am afraid of epigones... Same with Conan, though I haven't read any since childhood.

PPS. The secret (I think) to having and sharing a controversial opinion is to not be too emotionally attached to it. This is a worthy goal, and I try.

PPPS. I promise not to mention one S. King. I've only read one novel (The Shining) and he...does go on. And on. Oops there I did mention him after all.
Personally, I don't pit authors against one another, especially when they belong to the same lineage: Cisco, Ligotti, Campbell... even King, despite having been embraced by the mainstream. I believe in camaraderie when it comes to these things. In fact, I was recently having a conversation with Joseph Pulver's widow about something along these lines.

In any case, if I had to set up a literary showdown, instead of Stephen King vs. Thomas Ligotti, I'd go with Thomas Ligotti vs. Clive Barker... but that will never happen.

Clive Barker is incredible: his drawings, his personal imaginary world, his writing —though I've read very little of it— and his films, which are amazing.
 
Personally, I don't pit authors against one another, especially when they belong to the same lineage: Cisco, Ligotti, Campbell... even King, despite having been embraced by the mainstream. I believe in camaraderie when it comes to these things. In fact, I was recently having a conversation with Joseph Pulver's widow about something along these lines.

In any case, if I had to set up a literary showdown, instead of Stephen King vs. Thomas Ligotti, I'd go with Thomas Ligotti vs. Clive Barker... but that will never happen.

Clive Barker is incredible: his drawings, his personal imaginary world, his writing —though I've read very little of it— and his films, which are amazing.
I admit to not having read or seen anything by Clive Barker except Son of Celluloid, which was not my sort of thing (hoo boy). Also, I don't watch movies, so I am not qualified to speak on those. The literary showdown is something I might be missing the gist of because of age? I think a fairer fight would be King vs Barker. But I probably wouldn't watch it...

The only reason I mentioned Ligotti in conjunction with Cisco is because Ligotti blurbed the book I read, and I was mystified as to why. What I took from that are two things: one is that it doesn't mean anything, and I shouldn't give it any weight in the future, and the second is that there might be other reasons, like collegialism, or maybe Ligotti is a nice guy and couldn't find a kind way of saying no. Who knows? Not me.
 
I admit to not having read or seen anything by Clive Barker except Son of Celluloid, which was not my sort of thing (hoo boy). Also, I don't watch movies, so I am not qualified to speak on those. The literary showdown is something I might be missing the gist of because of age? I think a fairer fight would be King vs Barker. But I probably wouldn't watch it...

The only reason I mentioned Ligotti in conjunction with Cisco is because Ligotti blurbed the book I read, and I was mystified as to why. What I took from that are two things: one is that it doesn't mean anything, and I shouldn't give it any weight in the future, and the second is that there might be other reasons, like collegialism, or maybe Ligotti is a nice guy and couldn't find a kind way of saying no. Who knows? Not me.
Just for today... I'll commit an act of sacrilege.

Blurbs really aren't that big a deal; I've come to realize this from authors themselves. Some have told me that they ask certain people to write blurbs for their books. In fact, one of them was surprised to learn that someone had actually read the book before writing the blurb.

Thomas Ligotti... well, he supports his fellow writers and all that, which is certainly nice of him. We don't know him, we've never spoken to him, but I get the feeling that he agrees to these things out of goodwill and that particular sense of pulp camaraderie. A pretty clear example, along similar lines, was when he thanked Joseph Pulver for asking his permission to use Cynothoglys.

What I'm trying to say is... perhaps that blurb was simply a courtesy. I don't know. Personally, I don't rely on blurbs when deciding what to read. At this point, I don't think anyone should.

Photo courtesy of @Mr Fatigue:

FB_IMG_1786100969927.jpg
 
I don't watch movies, so I am not qualified to speak on those.

Do you mean you don't have a TV, and never go to the cinema? And for how long has this been going on? : )

Seriously though, I find it interesting, and think it may even be a benefit to the literature side of the mind.
 
Do you mean you don't have a TV, and never go to the cinema? And for how long has this been going on? : )

Seriously though, I find it interesting, and think it may even be a benefit to the literature side of the mind.
Yes, it does mean that, both those things. Though these days TV is slippery, since I have a computer and internet, of course. But I don't watch stuff in the sense that most people I know do. No shows, no talk shows, no politics (I read politics), no sports, no movies. I've watched the occasional short piece presented here just to try to be part of the group, but I'm mostly ambivalent at this point. My last cinema visit was October 2019. It was a documentary. My close friend wanted to take me, and I couldn't find a way to get out of it without being an asshole to her. But I still sometimes get pissy about it (not to her) to the point I have to make a conscious effort to stop thinking about it. She meant well, but it offended me the way she went about it that left me no choice.

I grew up without a TV in our house (small town Michigan in the 1960s and 1970s). I did see the occasional show at a friend's house, and there were two shows I really liked (Star Trek and Kung Fu) but I only got to see those a few times. I saw multiple episodes of Gilligan's Island, but there were many shows I never heard about until I was an adult. No Twilight Zone. No Night Gallery. No Saturday monster movies. No Elvira. My family got a TV when I was a junior in high school, but by then I was spending much time out of the house with friends getting high and playing records. I, in fact, was a record collector by then, and a reader of course, so I didn't watch it much. Plus, my friends thought we were too good for it. I did see the occasional movie in the cinema, of course.

When I moved out on my own, I realized I could choose. I chose no TV. I would see the occasional movie, and some of those were good. But mostly I read and played records. (One can do both at the same time!) I made this choice for the most youthfully pretentious of reasons, but eventually I began to realize that I was benefitting in ways I couldn't have understood before. My attention span was different. You likely know this yourself, but it takes a lifetime to begin to see it. I've watched plenty of movies over the years, but I generally find it difficult to sit through them now, since I've watched maybe fewer than ten in the past 25 years. I've found my brain processes information, including story, better through the written language.

But best of all has been NO ADS/COMMERCIALS. I don't have these things cluttering my brain. Also, no holiday noise. By the time Christmas arrives each year, I've had almost no exposure to it, so I can celebrate on my own terms. Another interesting thing that comes of this is that I'm lacking the cultural references that most people I know have. I'd know about certain celebrities just because it's hard to avoid that stuff, but also since I've never really had a long-term life partner, I've never had to compromise my life. The one time I did live with someone it didn't work. She wanted to watch movies several nights a week, and I thought they were all boring (to be fair, she didn't pick the ones I'd like), and would stay in the other room playing records. Of course it didn't work. So there's that.

PS. You might have gotten the impression that I've heard a lot of music. That is part of this picture. Our lives are defined by what we spend our time doing. I've been lonely at times, but the older I get, the less so. Would I do it all over again? Yes.
 
Gambling is bad.
Hey, R. I saw you "liked" my music post of Free. Did you see the one above it from Comus? I was thinking of you when I posted it. But maybe it's not so good...

And yeah, I agree on gambling. But I was very skeptical about Harrison winning, and still can't believe he did. He's one of my favorite writers, and they never get any recognition. To the point that I'm now afraid I'll have to share him with mainstream society, and it will all be ruined. And what has come over the Booker Prize that they picked his book? Is hell freezing over?
 
Hey, R. I saw you "liked" my music post of Free. Did you see the one above it from Comus? I was thinking of you when I posted it. But maybe it's not so good...

And yeah, I agree on gambling. But I was very skeptical about Harrison winning, and still can't believe he did. He's one of my favorite writers, and they never get any recognition. To the point that I'm now afraid I'll have to share him with mainstream society, and it will all be ruined. And what has come over the Booker Prize that they picked his book? Is hell freezing over?
I saw you guys talking about music, and I was actually going to do the same, but then I came across your conversation and ended up staying to read. I've been watching Twin Peaks and a few other things, so I haven't really had a chance to listen to music. Then I came here and, apart from the Booker Prize winner, I realized I feel the same way you do, Ironrose. I don't watch movies or TV shows; I don't even own a television. It's only now that I've decided to watch Twin Peaks because I wanted to see something by David Lynch. I'm just not drawn to movies or TV shows. They generally bore me. And when I do watch them, I give them my full attention, which takes up time, too. I feel like I've spent most of my life listening to more music and reading more books than watching TV or anything like that, and I'm not ashamed of it. I'll go check out the music thread now...
 
Back
Top