G. S. Carnivals";p="3518 said:
I'm afraid to peek at my 1985 Viking Dark Gods at the moment. And my three or four different versions of "The Events at Poroth Farm" must be even more maddening..
I've looked. Curiosity. Obsession. The Bantam reprint of "Black Man with a Horn" agrees with the Viking version. Well, at least that sentence does. The rest of the text is for someone else to examine....
My best determination is that at least five different versions of "The Events at Poroth Farm" exist. Klein himself from
Dagon 18/19:
" 'The Events at Porth Farm' (story) in
From Beyond the Dark Gateway, Vol. 1, No. 2 (December 1972), edited by Edward P. Berglund
Reprinted (slightly revised) in
The Year's Best Horror Stories, No. 3 edited by Richard Davis (London: Sphere, 1973)
Reprinted (slightly revised again) in
The Year's Best Horror Stories: Series II, edited by Richard Davis (New York: DAW, 1974)
Reprinted (slightly revised a third time) in
First World Fantasy Awards edited by Gahan Wilson (New York: Doubleday, 1977)"
As for later printings, a fifth version is extant in the 1990 Necronomicon Press chapbook of the tale. This is replicated in the anthology
Return to Lovecraft Country edited by Scott David Aniolowski (Triad Entertainments, 1997). Mr. Aniolowski's acknowledgements read: " ... and Marc Michaud at Necronomicon Press for providing me with a disk of T.E.D. Klein's excellent contribution, and allowing me to reproduce the Necronomicon Press edition of the story here..."
The story is also in
Eternal Lovecraft edited by Jim Turner (Golden Gryphon, 1998). I have no idea what this version is. Five again, or six? I'm not checking. Honest.
In uprooting my house, I discovered yet another copy each of the Bantam
Dark Gods and
The Ceremonies that I didn't know I had. I've been gifting my extras. candy gets lucky.